Doubting disbelievers: A new approach to measuring religious uncertainty

April 1, 2019 | Daniel A. Cox

Key Points

  • Most Americans believe in God, but doubts are more common than is often reported. Nearly half (46 percent) of the public express some amount of uncertainty about the exis­tence of God.
  • Nonbelievers have doubts about God too. More than one-quarter of atheists report that they are not completely certain that God does not exist. Atheists express greater doubts about the existence of God than white evangelical Protestants do.
  • Religious doubting is particularly common among young adults. About only one-third (34 percent) of young people believe in God and are certain about their beliefs. Nearly 6 in 10 young adults express some degree of uncertainty about God’s existence.

Read the full PDF. 

Introduction 

A belief in God is among the most common religious beliefs held by the public. It is a belief that transcends most religious affiliations, including those who report having none. Theistic belief has also been quite stable over time even as the US has experienced an unprece­dented amount of cultural and demographic change.

By most measures, roughly 9 in 10 Americans report believing in God or a universal spirit. However, per­spectives on God are incredibly varied. A recent report by the Pew Research Center documented the diversity of beliefs about God, including the nature of God and God’s role in human affairs.1

There are also stark differences in the degree to which Americans are certain about their religious beliefs. Early measures of theistic belief that offered binary response options to questions about God con­veyed a level of certainty that subsequent research efforts began to question. A new research approach finds that doubts about God are even more prevalent than previous surveys suggest—a pattern that is evi­dent among believers and nonbelievers alike.

Read the full report. 

Notes

1. The Pew Research Center, “When Americans Say They Believe in God, What Do They Mean?,” April 25, 2018, http://www.pewforum.org/2018/04/25/when-americans-say-they-believe-in-god-what-do-they-mean/.

Survey Reports

An illustration of the side profiles of four people. From left to right: a young white man with blond hair, an older Black woman with short, curly Black hair, a young woman with tan skin and black hair with a blue streak, an older man with darker tan skin with curly grey hair and a mustache.

Daniel A. Cox, Beatrice Lee, Dana Popky
April 27, 2022

Politics, Sex, and Sexuality: The Growing Gender Divide in American Life

The March 2022 American Perspectives Survey examines the growing gender divide in American Life.

Daniel A. Cox
March 24, 2022

Generation Z and the Future of Faith in America

Data from the American National Family Life Survey paints a complicated picture of religious change and disaffiliation in the country today.

Daniel A. Cox
February 9, 2022

Emerging Trends and Enduring Patterns in American Family Life

The American National Family Life Survey examines the changing contours of American family life in the country today.

bridge between college graduates and those without a degree

Daniel A. Cox
December 13, 2021

The College Connection: The Education Divide in American Social and Community Life

The 2021 American Community Life Survey illuminates the growing social divide between Americans with college educations and those without.